SC/ST Act Explained: Rights, Misuse Claims

The Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, commonly known as the SC/ST Act, is one of India’s most important social justice laws. It was enacted to protect members of Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST) from discrimination, violence, humiliation, and exploitation.

Despite its strong objectives, the Act has often been in the news due to debates around alleged misuse, arrests without inquiry, and concerns raised by the general public. At the same time, SC/ST communities continue to face serious atrocities, proving the continued relevance of the Act.

This article explains the SC/ST Act in simple language, covering:

Rights provided under the Act
What constitutes an offence
Punishments
Misuse claims and controversies
Legal safeguards and Supreme Court guidelines

What is the SC/ST Act?

The SC/ST Act was enacted in 1989 and came into force in 1990. The main purpose of the Act is to:

Prevent atrocities against SC/ST members
Provide special courts for speedy trials
Ensure relief, rehabilitation, and compensation to victims
Create a deterrent through strict punishment

The Act recognizes that existing laws like the IPC were insufficient to deal with caste-based crimes.

Who is Protected Under the Act?

The Act applies when:

Victim belongs to Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe
Accused does not belong to SC/ST

If both parties belong to SC/ST, the Act generally does not apply, though IPC sections may still be used.

What are “Atrocities” Under the SC/ST Act?

The Act defines specific acts as atrocities. Some important ones include:

Calling a person by caste name in public
Insulting or intimidating to humiliate based on caste

2. Physical Violence

Assault, use of force, or injury
Sexual exploitation of SC/ST women

Forcibly taking land or property
Dispossessing someone from their land

4. Denial of Rights

Preventing entry into temples, shops, or public places
Forcing manual scavenging or bonded labor

5. Legal Harassment

Filing false cases against SC/ST persons
Giving false evidence to harm an SC/ST individual

Punishment Under the SC/ST Act

The punishments are stringent and include:

Imprisonment (minimum 6 months to life imprisonment)
Fine
Enhanced punishment if offence is repeated
Public servants face stricter consequences if they neglect duty

Important Features of the SC/ST Act

1. Non-Bailable Offences

Most offences under the Act are non-bailable, meaning bail is not automatic.

2. No Anticipatory Bail (Earlier)

Originally, anticipatory bail was barred under Section 18 of the Act.

3. Special Courts

Exclusive Special Courts and Special Public Prosecutors are appointed.

4. Victim Compensation

Victims are entitled to:

Immediate relief
Monetary compensation
Rehabilitation and protection

SC/ST Act Amendment, 2018

The 2018 Amendment strengthened the Act by:

Reintroducing immediate arrest
Removing preliminary inquiry before FIR
Reinforcing victim protection

This amendment came after concerns that earlier safeguards weakened the law.

Misuse Claims: Why is the SC/ST Act Controversial?

One of the biggest debates around the Act is its alleged misuse.

Common Allegations of Misuse:

False cases filed to settle personal disputes
Used as a tool for revenge or pressure
Immediate arrest without inquiry harms innocent persons

Several courts have acknowledged that misuse does occur, but they have also emphasized that misuse cannot be a reason to dilute a welfare law.

Supreme Court on SC/ST Act Misuse

Subhash Kashinath Mahajan Case (2018)

The Supreme Court initially held:

Preliminary inquiry before FIR
Approval required before arrest of public servants

This judgment caused nationwide protests.

Parliament’s Response

The government passed the 2018 Amendment, overriding the judgment and restoring stricter provisions.

Later Clarification by Supreme Court (2020)

The Court clarified:

Courts can grant anticipatory bail in exceptional cases
If no prima facie case is made out, protection can be given
Magistrates must apply judicial mind

Legal Safeguards Against False Cases

While the Act is strict, legal safeguards do exist:

1. Judicial Scrutiny

Courts must examine whether a prima facie offence is made out.

2. Anticipatory Bail (Exceptional Cases)

If the complaint appears motivated or false, courts can grant relief.

3. Quashing of FIR

High Courts can quash FIRs under Section 482 CrPC (now BNSS provisions).

4. Penalty for False Complaints

Filing a false case can lead to prosecution under:

IPC Sections for false evidence
Defamation
Perjury

Rights of Victims Under the SC/ST Act

Victims enjoy strong legal rights, including:

Right to immediate FIR registration
Protection from threats or intimidation
Free legal aid
Compensation at different stages of the case
Right to speedy trial

The Act places responsibility on District Magistrates and police officers to ensure victim safety.

Duties of Police & Administration

Police officers must:

Register FIR immediately
Not delay investigation
Provide protection to victims and witnesses

Failure to perform duties can result in:

Departmental action
Criminal liability under the Act

SC/ST Act vs Fundamental Rights Debate

Critics argue that:

Immediate arrest violates Article 21 (Right to Life & Liberty)

Supporters argue that:

Social inequality requires special protection
Historical oppression justifies stricter laws

The judiciary has tried to balance both interests—protecting victims while preventing abuse.

Practical Advice for Common Citizens

If You Are a Victim:

File FIR immediately
Approach District Magistrate for relief
Seek legal aid
Preserve evidence and witnesses

If You Are Falsely Accused:

Consult a lawyer immediately
Apply for anticipatory bail if possible
Approach High Court for quashing
Maintain proof of false implication

Conclusion

The SC/ST Act is a powerful and necessary law aimed at protecting some of the most vulnerable sections of Indian society. While concerns about misuse cannot be ignored, they should not overshadow the continuing reality of caste-based discrimination and violence.

The solution lies not in weakening the Act, but in:

Responsible enforcement
Judicial oversight
Awareness among citizens

A balanced approach ensures justice for victims while safeguarding the rights of the innocent.

✍️ About LawKiBaat.in

At lawkibaat.in, we explain Indian laws in simple language so that every citizen knows their rights and duties.